Carol,
One of my ancestors, William Shuster b. 1844 come to Jerseyville, Illinois and married Sarah Elizabeth McGee on Jan. 29, 1874. This William was the son of Henry Shuster b. 1816 and his first wife Nancy Schaffer Shuster. Nancy Schaffer Shuster apparently died in or about 1847 after the fifth child was born or was being born. Henry Shuster now married a Juliann Ramey Shuster in 1848.
Now my line actually come down from Henry Shuster's brother Abraham born in 1803. Abraham from Morgan Co. Ohio came/went into Iowa (VanBuren County) in the early 1840's.
If this has any ring of similarity let me know and/or try contacting Sheri Shuster the husband of Wayne Shuster. Wayne is a more direct descendent of this William that came to or through the Jerseyville area. Sheri is the genealogist of the family.
Leslie Shuster