Kruger, John F. - looking for relatives and where he was from

HiI cannot find the place of birth of my great grandfather, JohannFriedrich Krüger. Could you offer some suggestions ?Could you help me find his relatives ?
CAME TO THIS COUNTRY

We have different dates as to when he may have come to this country:
1. 1864 Source is his obituary. age 16
2. June 25th 1867 Source is his first naturalization papers. age 19
3. 1867 Source is the 1910 and 1920 census of MN age 19
4. 1870 Source is the 1900 census. age 22
5. 1870 Source is the 1905 Minnesota state census. age 22 when he came to usa.
So 3 records say 1867 is when he came(his first naturalization record, census of 1910 and 1920.

Prussia is same like Preussen. Posen (today Poznan) is a city in Poland.
And unfortuntely the name Kruger/Krüger is as frequently as Smith or Tailor :frowning:

Grüße von Heide

PLACES
OF BIRTH:
John (JOHANN) Friedrich (Fred) /Krüger/. Born 16 Aug 1847 in
Prussia.
We are trying to find out where he was born in Prussia.
Different
places of birth for John.
1. On my ggrandfather's naturalization papers he said
he was from Prussia.
2. His obituary says he was from Preusen, Germany. Died in
Barnesville, Minnesota, USA. Preusen also sounds like Posen.

-----Ursprüngliche Mitteilung-----

Hi Alan

It sounds like you are searching for a needle in a haystack. The real estate you mention in your note covers some 120,000 square miles and at that time period had a population in excess of 40 million people.

The question you really will need to ask yourself is:

  * If I found you one Johann Friedrich Krüger... but would it be yours?
    How would you know?

So we need something 'unique' to research and compare against.

Additionally you need to be aware that the areas of East/West Prussia, Pomerania, and Posen you mention lost between 30-90% of their church records (varying by location... and accuracy of allied munitions in WW2). I am certain I speak for many people on this list when I say, I'd love to help, but you really need to give me something to work with like:

  * his birth town, village, province(I know you already said you don't
    know these things)
  * his language (spoken & written)
  * family customs which may have come 'through' him
  * any photos of the old country
  * letters that may have been sent to/from his 'relatives' in the old
    country
  * financial donation arrangements that may have existed with German
    family in WW1 or WW2
  * notes from a family bible
  * other people from Germany that he may have moved in with when he
    came to the US
  * other Germans in his community, where did they come from?

You might also find this article helpful, if you haven't already seen it: Prussian/ German Genealogy Help – ManyRoads

Beyond that, there really is nothing very useful that can be done...

Pax vobiscum,

Pax vobiscum,
...mark

Guten Morgen, Elisabeth,

es kam nach Kriegseintritt der Amerikaner in den 1. Weltkrieg und nach dem Krieg
vielerorts in den USA zu antideutschen Ausschreitungen. Nachzulesen z.B. hier:
<http://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geschichte_der_Deutschen_in_den_Vereinigten_Staaten&gt;

und dann abwärts scrollen bis zum Kapitel 1. Weltkrieg.

Diese Ausschreitungen waren der Grund, dass Amerikaner deutscher Abstammung ihre
Herkunft verleugneten und stattdessen Elsass, Luxemburg, Dänemark oder eben Prag
als Herkunft abgaben.

Die Vorfahren des Allen Krueger kamen mit Sicherheit aus Preußen und die Spur
der Krüger hier aufzunehmen, halte ich für schier unmöglich.

Gruß von Peter Pankau

Das ist ein wichtiger Hinweis von Peter Pankau! So wird es sich auch in diesem Fall verhalten haben, denn das Abschw�ren jeglicher Loyalit�t dem K�nig von Preu�en gegen�ber bei der Einb�rgerung beweist, dass die wahre Herkunft das K�nigreich Preu�en mit seinen weit gestreckten Provinzen gewesen sein m u s s .

N�heres lie�e sich nur �ber ein Suchen in den Akten des Ankunftsortes in den USA und anschlie�end (wenn man den Namen des Auswandererschiffes heraus gefunden hat) �ber die des Ausreiseortes in Europa (vermutlich in Deutschland) feststellen. Nur auf diesem Wege g�be es eine M�glichkeit, zu den Vorfahren vorzudringen.

Gru� Rolf-Peter